Debugging the Longest Valid Parentheses Algorithm: Preserving the Original Thought Process

In the world of programming, tackling problems related to parentheses is a common and often challenging task. One such problem is finding the length of the longest valid parentheses substring within a given string. Today, we’ll dive into a JavaScript implementation of this problem that a developer shared, exploring its logic and identifying potential improvements while preserving the original thought process.

Understanding the Problem

The problem is straightforward: given a string s consisting of characters ( and ), we need to determine the length of the longest substring that is a valid combination of these characters. A valid combination means every opening parenthesis has a corresponding closing parenthesis in the correct order.

The Original Implementation

Let’s first take a look at the original code shared by the developer:

javascript /**

• @param {string} s

• @return {number} */ var longestValidParentheses = function(s) {

  // if there are more open than close, there is hope // but if there are more close, what we do ?

  // (( ))()), then we have to restart, right ?

  let i = 0; let longest = 0; let stack = []; let max = 0;

  while(i < s.length) {

   if(s[i] == '(') {
       stack.push(')');
  
       // ()(()
       let lengthRemaining = s.length - 1 - i; 
  
       if(stack.length > lengthRemaining) {
           longest = 0;
       }
  
   } else {
       if(stack.length && stack[stack.length-1] == ')') {
           stack.pop();
           longest = longest + 2; // where we reset this ? (()) ()
           max = Math.max(max, longest);
       } else {
           longest = 0;
       }
   }
   ++i;
  

  }

  return max; };

Breakdown of the Code

1. Initialization: The code initializes several variables:

   • i is the index to iterate through the string.
   • longest keeps track of the length of the current valid parentheses substring.
   • stack is used to track the parentheses.
   • max stores the maximum length of valid parentheses found.

2. Iteration through the string: The function uses a while loop to iterate through the string character by character.

3. Handling Open Parentheses: If the current character is (, it pushes a ) onto the stack and checks if the stack length exceeds the remaining length of the string. If it does, it resets the longest variable.

4. Handling Close Parentheses: If the current character is ), it checks if there’s a matching ( in the stack. If there is, it pops from the stack, increments the longest variable by 2, and updates max if longest exceeds it. If there’s no match, it resets longest.

5. Returning the Result: Finally, the function returns max, which is the length of the longest valid parentheses substring.

Identifying Issues

While the original thought process and code structure have merit, there are some issues and inefficiencies that need to be addressed:

1. Incorrect Length Calculation: The logic for resetting longest based on the length of the stack and remaining string is flawed. It can lead to incorrect results, especially for cases where valid substrings are separated by invalid characters.

2. Stack Usage: Using the stack to track the expected closing parentheses is a good idea, but the current implementation does not utilize it effectively to determine valid substrings.

3. Resetting Longest: The condition for resetting longest can lead to missed opportunities for valid substrings that have been partially counted.

A Revised Approach

To improve the implementation, we can maintain a stack to keep track of indices of unmatched parentheses. This allows us to easily calculate the length of valid substrings when we encounter a match.

Here’s a revised version of the code:

javascript var longestValidParentheses = function(s) { let max = 0; let stack = [-1]; // Initialize with -1 to handle edge cases

for (let i = 0; i < s.length; i++) {
    if (s[i] === '(') {
        stack.push(i); // Push the index of '('
    } else {
        stack.pop(); // Pop the last open index
        if (stack.length === 0) {
            stack.push(i); // Push current index as a new base
        } else {
            max = Math.max(max, i - stack[stack.length - 1]); // Calculate length
        }
    }

Related Posts

• Leetcode 340 - Longest Substring with At Most K Distinct Characters
• Palindromic String Problem for Parenthesis
• Manacher’s Algorithm